The evaluation of any system that must always operate in the
context of other systems is like trying to fix the hands on the
clock when the spring is broken. In order to get full
value of any change we must see that it will integrate with the
whole system of managing our legislature. For
example: How can we increase accountability, which
means identifying our representative's actions on our behalf when
he or she cannot vote our wishes or even with his or
her conscience? If we are to tinker with how
we select our representatives we must also see that they are given
the chance to get the results we are looking for. As
long as the 'party line' system of voting exists we will not
improve democracy. I would like to see the Assembly
include some assumptions upon which they can base a recommendation
for a real improvement in the features we are looking
for. A list of those assumptions could include:
1. Eliminate votes of 'confidence'. No
snap elections, they are in there for four years and must make the
best of it. Under-governing isn't a bad thing.
2. Members are always allowed to vote freely -- and
be ready to justify their actions to their
constituents. This will mean they must understand the
issues, both for the province and their constituents.
It isn't an easy road but a reasoned response is all we ask -- a
discussion of the pros and cons in public would help.
3. Committees will be given responsibilities and
powers as subsets of the legislature as a whole. This
is the only way to get work done.
4. Appointments to committees will be decided by the
legislature, not the government; this supplements the free vote
idea.
5. Premiers will no longer be the majority party
leader, but be selected by all of the elected members of the
legislature. There might be a better person
available.
6. Make a clear separation between the politicians
and the bureaucracy. The money will be spent based on
votes -- no discretionary funds. We should see reserves
for catastrophes that might not be spent every year.
There should not be any 'spending' during the last fiscal quarter
to 'use up' excess funds.
It is only with a clear understanding of how the legislature
actually works that our rules of selection can be modified for a
better result.
|
levelCMS